Wed December 16, 2026

SHOULD HUCKLEBERRY FINN BE BANNED FROM OUR SCHOOLS — FOR ITS OWN GOOD?

The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn has been in trouble almost from the moment Mark Twain published it, first in Britain in 1884 and then in the United States in 1885. The original objections included Huck's bad behavior and socially subversive thinking, but also the book's bad grammar and unconventional language.

Today, many objections center on Twain's unflinching depiction of the language, assumptions and brutality of a white supremacist society, including the novel's use of racist language toward Black people. That depiction can be painful and deeply disturbing. But many argue that Twain's target was the society that produced and normalized that dehumanization, not the people who suffered under it.

That distinction matters. Jim, a fugitive from enslavement, is among the novel's most humane and admirable characters. Again and again, Jim's compassion, loyalty, intelligence and moral judgment expose the failures of the white characters and the society around them.

The question we are debating now is whether the descendants of enslaved people, and more broadly children growing up in America, should be exposed to Huckleberry Finn. But perhaps the more useful question is what we lose if we stop reading it. Twain gives us an unflinching record of a society built on racial cruelty and asks us to see the gap between that society's values and its behavior. The discomfort is not incidental to the book. It is part of what the book is doing.

In 2025, the National Endowment for the Humanities ended nearly 60 years of federal funding for the Mark Twain Papers and Project and attempted to claw back a grant that had already been promised. The decision raises a larger question about Twain himself. Is he no longer worthy of public support from either side of the political spectrum? The left has long wrestled with the racist language in Huckleberry Finn, while the right has its own reasons to be uncomfortable with Twain, whose work was fiercely skeptical of American institutions, wealth, imperialism and the powerful.

Perhaps those competing rejections are one reason Twain remains worth reading. Huckleberry Finn is not a comfortable book, and neither is the history it depicts. But discomfort is not necessarily a reason to stop reading. Sometimes it is a reason to read more carefully, argue more honestly, and ask what the book is asking us to see.

And perhaps that is the lesson of Twain's maxim: "Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to reform--or pause & reflect."

Join us for a panel discussion with Shelley Fisher Fishkin, author of Jim: The Life and Afterlives of Huckleberry Finn's Comrade, Keli Dailey, whose essay "Rereading Mark Twain While Everything Else Burns" inspired this program, and Kerry Driscoll, from The Mark Twain Papers and Project at the Bancroft Library at UC-Berkeley, and author of Mark Twain Among the Indians and Other Indigenous Peoples.

ORGANIZER
George Hammond
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn has been in trouble almost from the moment Mark Twain published it, first in Britain in 1884 and then in the United States in 1885. The original objections included Huck's bad behavior and socially subversive thinking, but also the book's bad grammar and unconventional language.

Today, many objections center on Twain's unflinching depiction of the language, assumptions and brutality of a white supremacist society, including the novel's use of racist language toward Black people. That depiction can be painful and deeply disturbing. But many argue that Twain's target was the society that produced and normalized that dehumanization, not the people who suffered under it.

That distinction matters. Jim, a fugitive from enslavement, is among the novel's most humane and admirable characters. Again and again, Jim's compassion, loyalty, intelligence and moral judgment expose the failures of the white characters and the society around them.

The question we are debating now is whether the descendants of enslaved people, and more broadly children growing up in America, should be exposed to Huckleberry Finn. But perhaps the more useful question is what we lose if we stop reading it. Twain gives us an unflinching record of a society built on racial cruelty and asks us to see the gap between that society's values and its behavior. The discomfort is not incidental to the book. It is part of what the book is doing.

In 2025, the National Endowment for the Humanities ended nearly 60 years of federal funding for the Mark Twain Papers and Project and attempted to claw back a grant that had already been promised. The decision raises a larger question about Twain himself. Is he no longer worthy of public support from either side of the political spectrum? The left has long wrestled with the racist language in Huckleberry Finn, while the right has its own reasons to be uncomfortable with Twain, whose work was fiercely skeptical of American institutions, wealth, imperialism and the powerful.

Perhaps those competing rejections are one reason Twain remains worth reading. Huckleberry Finn is not a comfortable book, and neither is the history it depicts. But discomfort is not necessarily a reason to stop reading. Sometimes it is a reason to read more carefully, argue more honestly, and ask what the book is asking us to see.

And perhaps that is the lesson of Twain's maxim: "Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to reform--or pause & reflect."

Join us for a panel discussion with Shelley Fisher Fishkin, author of Jim: The Life and Afterlives of Huckleberry Finn's Comrade, Keli Dailey, whose essay "Rereading Mark Twain While Everything Else Burns" inspired this program, and Kerry Driscoll, from The Mark Twain Papers and Project at the Bancroft Library at UC-Berkeley, and author of Mark Twain Among the Indians and Other Indigenous Peoples.

ORGANIZER
George Hammond
read more
show less
   
EDIT OWNER
Owned by
{{eventOwner.email_address || eventOwner.displayName}}
New Owner

Update

EDIT EDIT
Date/Times:
  • Wed Dec 16 (6pm)
The Commonwealth Club 4 Upcoming Events
110 The Embarcadero, San Francisco, CA 94105

SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA EVENTS CALENDAR

TODAY
27
SATURDAY
28
SUNDAY
29
MONDAY
1
The Best Events
Every Week in Your Inbox

Thank you for subscribing!

Edit Event Details

I am the event organizer



Your suggestion is required.



Your email is required.
Not valid email!

    Cancel
Great suggestion! We'll be in touch.
Event reviewed successfully.

Success!

Your event is now LIVE on SF STATION

COPY LINK TO SHARE Copied

or share on


See my event listing


Looking for more visibility? Reach more people with our marketing services