After the deaths of the two intrepid Shreve brothers, the store was incorporated as Shreve & Co. in 1894, with George Rodman, the son of George Shreve, as president and partner Albert J. Lewis as the majority stockholder.
More recently, Shreve & Co. has prided itself on a variety of special exhibits, such as the Goldsmith's Hall silver from England, the international award-winning DeBeers Diamond Contest pieces and the treasures salvaged from the sunken Spanish galleon, The Atocha.